Craig, 33
Hometown: Lake Ronkonkoma, N.Y.
Occupation: Personal trainer, actor
Bio fun fact: One of his favorite memories to this day is getting a puppy for Christmas when he was 7. He and his sister named her Nala, after Simba's wife in The Lion King.
Most festive thing he's ever done: "I dressed up as an elf — like really dressed up as an elf," says Craig. "Not just a hat. I was unrecognizable."
