Guest Stars Nate Torrence as Dylan Killington Lucy Davis as Lucy Kenwright Ayda Field as Jeannie Whatley Simon Helberg as Alex Dwyer Camille Chen as Samantha Li Mark McKinney as Andy Mackinaw John Mahon as George Josh Stamberg as Luke Scott Kari Matchett as Mary Tate J.D. Walsh as Jess (Emergency Room Doctor) James Lesure as Captain David Boyle Michael Stuhlbarg as Jerry Amy Hill as Nurse Annette Matt McCoy as Russell Tom Virtue as Leon Cushman Rich Hutchman as Reporter Co Starring John F. Carpenter as Herb Sheldon John Ennis as Denny Wendle Josepher as Deb John Cabrera as Elliot Ben Murray as Louis Mel Fair as Newscaster Mark Bloom as Reporter #2 Gina St. John as Reporter #1 Leyna Nguyen as News Anchor Matt Weinhold as Actor / Hannibal