Special Guest Stars James Cromwell as Jack "J.R." Randall Guest Stars Laura Benanti as USPIS Agent Edie Mamoudou Athie as Carl Laura Hughes as Laura Matthew Hetherington as Levi Co Starring Mary Kraft as Shelly Amy Shiels as Nicole Kevin Townley as Martin Jocelyn Bioh as Isabel Christina Collard as Naomi Anna Cameron as Cate Olli Haaskivi as Church Assistant David Bluvband as Creepy Weirdo Sarah Rich as Margot Amy Waller as Kylie Akira Ito as IRS Drone