A kid named Nick (Jarrett Lennon) gets kidnapped and when his mother Rose (Eve Plumb) reaches to Lois and Clark for help, the two of them start to investigate all the recent kidnappings of children. The way Nick was kidnapped - through a magic box decorated with moons and stars - leads them to a magic club where they meet the magicianAndre Novak (Ben Vereen). While they are trying to find clues to connect Novak to the kidnappings, Superman confronts the kidnapper himself during the exchange of money for Nick, but the kidnapper hypnotizes him into thinking that "wrong is right" and Superman starts doing weird things everytime he hears the phrase "moon and stars". Eventually, Lois finds Nick and when Superman arrives for help, they discover that behind the kidnappings is Constance (Marietta DePrima), the assistance of Darrin Romick (Penn Jillette), another magician who works with Novak. Constance not only is responsible for the kidnappings and for hypnotizing Superman, but she also hypnotized Romick into killing Novak. Superman manages to fight the hypnosis, saves everyone and Constance gets arrested.