Guest Stars Ari Graynor as Rachel Dunham Spencer List as Michael Erik Palladino as Eliot Michaels Victor Williams as Phil Co Starring Lily Pilblad as Ella Blake Chad Gittens as ND FBI Tech Robyn Payne as NID FBI Agent Lecy Goranson as Samantha Gilmore Jeremy Shamos as The Artist Jimmy Palumbo as Mike Phil Nee as Archie Donelly Sandra Daley as Dr. Winick Matt Mulhern as Dennis Carolyn Feldschuh as Older Woman Carrie Keranen as Kate Harper Mary Lou Schriber as Nurse Uncredited Michael Cerveris as September
