Special Guest Stars John Lithgow as Arthur Mitchell Guest Stars Geoff Pierson as Thomas Matthews Brando Eaton as Jonah Mitchell Vanessa Marano as Rebecca Mitchell Julia Campbell as Sally Mitchell Mary Mara as Valerie Hodges Jake Short as Scott Smith Jim Metzler as Special Agent Davis Co Starring Christina Robinson as Astor Bennett Preston Bailey as Cody Bennett Roger Ranney as Nick Smith John Littlefield as Deputy Jullian Dulce Vida as Julio Christopher Goodman as Angry Driver Geno Monteiro as Officer