Guest Stars Dennis Boutsikaris as Josh Beekman Deborah Hedwall as Lieutenant Wade Alicia Coppola as Detective Patricia Damiana William Hill as Augustus McTeague Leo Burmester as Father Peter Castoro Jamie Harrold as Niall Elizabeth Rodriguez as Del Bianco Linda Larkin as Alycia Ron McLarty as Father John Kevin Carolan as Desk Sgt. Bonfiglio Judy Reyes as Allison Yul Vazquez as Mr. Cupideros Joshua Dov as White Guy With Dread Locks Vera Farmiga as Mrs. Cupideros Orlagh Cassidy as Co-Worker Robert Prescott as Bush Gregory Gilmore as Driver Carrie Jones as Petra Micki Paley as Girl Next To Petra Greg Haberny as Other Band Guy Richard Muenz as Tall Guy Ti-Hua Chang as Himself Taylor Dressman as Nestor Cupideros Anthony Fusco as Bryan Wolf Robert T. Bogue as Caleb Trevor Robert Jimenez as Niki Colon Mark Fish as Guy With Nylon Jesus Shirt