Guest Stars Dennis Boutsikaris as Josh Beekman Deborah Hedwall as Lieutenant Wade Skipp Sudduth as Jerry McCaffrey William Hill as Augustus McTeague Leo Burmester as Father Peter Castoro Amy Ryan as Siobhan Thom Sesma as Gabriel Kevin Chamberlin as Big Ric Spencer Breslin as Little Kid JoAnna Rhinehart as Obstetrician Madison Arnold as Junior Tracie Jade as Dorothy Angela Lanza as Amber Tillman Damian D. Lewis as Jamaican Guy Ken Marks as Dr. Kaplan Maryann Urbano as Betty McCaffrey Nicholas J. Giangiulio as Santa