Guest Stars Samantha Ferris as Lieutenant Alexa Brenner Noelle Beck as Inspector Jessica Sykes Pascale Hutton as Jocelyn Gallo Chelah Horsdal as Ivy Beckman Zak Santiago as Nicholas Chavez Adrian Holmes as Craig Park Tim Perez as Jesus Campanos Lorena Gale as Agent Fisher Susan Chuang as Susan Tran Andrew Jackson as Oliver Beckman Co Starring Mark Adair-Rios as The Tooth Fairy Fred Keating as Duty Sergeant Mills Link Baker as Officer Healy Sean Tyson as The Uniformed Officer Val Cole as The Journalist Andrew Kavadas as Officer Jered Blount Nicolas Von Zill as The Fisherman Pamela MacDonald as Cecily