Guest Stars Michael Fairman as Judge Douglas McGrath Raye Birk as Judge Steven Lang Stephen Root as Attorney Brandon McCafferty Mariangela Pino as Hortense Krieger Greg Germann as Larry Greenhut George Wyner as Aaron Voss Donald May as Andrew Laraby Michael Lembeck as Mitchell Schein Mimi Maynard as Alison Schein Barbara Stuart as Marion Laraby Stephen Burleigh as Jonah Berkowitz Clarence Felder as Mel Rechtschaefer Rudolph Willrich as Evan Pontell Robert Neches as Leo Krakower Mark Schneider as Marvin Stone Scott LaRose as Kyle Thunder William Kramer as Rabbi Roman Cisneros as Francisco Aguilar Co Starring Susan Burke as Jury Foreperson Chaim Tsvi Karp as Rabbinical Student #1 Reuven Nathanson as Rabbinical Student #2 Uncredited Theodore Carl Soderberg as Law Student