Guest Stars Aiden Lovekamp as Buddy Quinn Sprague Grayden as Jill Usman Ally as Arthur Morris Todd Robert Anderson as Patrick O'Brien Jen Drohan as Amy Bob Stephenson as Adam Lever Co Starring Cheyenne Haynes as Young Noelle Cameron Kasal as Young RJ Maeve Tomalty as Young Caroline Tiffany Brouwer as Caroline Palmer Reggie Brown as Reporter