Guest Stars Joe Morton as Eli Pope Portia de Rossi as Elizabeth North Brian Letscher as Tom Larsen Paul Adelstein as Leo Bergen Vanya Asher as Ethan Matthew Del Negro as Michael Ambruso Mackenzie Astin as Noah Baker Molly Baker as Rachel Jasika Nicole as Kimberly Muñoz Jaden Betts as Javi Tim Ransom as Jeremy Winslow Asante Jones as Reporter Martin Sal Viscuso as Clark Brian Benben as Leonard Carnehan Carol Locatell as Bitsy Cooper Raymond Forchion as Judge Lancaster