Guest Stars Violet Brinson as Kelsey David Sullivan as Chris April Brinson as Jodes Barbara Eve Harris as Eileen Curry Emily Yancy as Gayla Beth Broderick as Annie B Catherine Carlen as Deeanna Loretta Fox as Melissa Jennifer Aspen as Jeannie Keene Randy Oglesby as Pastor Betsy Baker as Jocelyn Vickery Guy Boyd as Clyde D.B. Sweeney as Dad Keene Co Starring Jessica Treska as Natalie Keene Kaegan Baron as Ann Nash Daisy Garcia as Bar Waitress Iyana Halley as Mae Tom Simmons as Judge Keno K. Deary as Paramedic Melinda Ratner as Court Clerk Sameerah Luqmaan-Harris as Mae's Mom