Guest Stars Alyssa Diaz as Teresa Elliott Gould as Ezra Goldman William Stanford Davis as Potato Pie Denise Crosby as Deb Goldman Leland Orser as Father Thomas Romero Katie Holmes as Paige Finney Ian McShane as Andrew Finney Jason Butler Harner as Varick Strauss Fairuza Balk as Ginger Shree Grace Crooks as Audrey Guy Burnet as Casey Finney Chris Browning as Gary Royal
