Guest Stars Anne Dudek as Benedicte Schaeffer Michael Rispoli as Wilkie Dino Rende as John Schaeffer Kyle Bornheimer as Paul Rodney Rowland as Rodney Bosch Nicole Forester as Donna Russell Kaleigh Loughridge as Molly Russell Tony Marino as Brian Russell Christian Keiber as Toby Gunder Constance Brenneman as Maggie Warner Will Blagrove as Donnie Knapp Jason McCune as Kevin Russell Donald Pasquarelli as Don the Cop Mackenzie Nelson as Abbey Warner Reis Ciarmitaro as Connor Warner Roy James Wilson as Eddie Reidenbach Patrick Jordan as George Otte
