Guest Stars Justin Kirk as Peter Bernard White as Scott Perera Julitta Dee Scheel as Cassidy Tara Lipinski as Herself Barry Rothbart as Bert Jennie Pierson as Sara Lipinski Louis Ozawa Changchien as Mr. Pickles-San Riki Lindhome as Shaina Co Starring Alex Raul Barrios as Derrell Coda Boesel as B.D. Juliocesar Chavez as Gigs Patrick Johnson as The Oops / Maestro Fermata / Puppeteer Mary Faber as Macy Joel Swetow as Rabbi Michael Epstein Karen Huie as Marsha Samira Izadi as Shelly Pinsker Jernard Burks as Denny Calah Lane as Denny's Little Girl Natasha Khawja as Grace Kisakye Maximus Birchmore as Tanner Tice Proctor as Child on the Couch with Jeff Melissa Schumacher as Stage Manager Anders Garrett as Julian Reese Gonzales as Party Kid Aiden Arnold as Marvin Amelia Fischer as Carolina