Guest Stars Sarah Gadon as Elisa Montgomery Brett Cullen as Gerald Kindt Isaiah C. Morgan as Young Henry Hays Jon Tenney as Alan Jones Rhys Wakefield as Freddy Burns Michael Greyeyes as Brett Woodard Kennedi Lynn Butler as Young Becca Hays Josh Hopkins as Jim Dobkins Tim Griffin as Special Agent Burt Diller James MacDonald as Major Blevins Bea Santos as Adult Julie Purcell Scott Shepherd as Officer Harris James Brian Oerly as Eddie Michael Broderick as Special Agent John Bowen Myk Watford as Detective Morelli Bill Kelly as Detective Hobbs David Stanbra as Detective Segar L. Warren Young as 90's Detective #4 Jodi Balfour as Lori Cullen Moss as Arkansas State Trooper Katy Harris as Fran Elisha Pratt as David Woodard TC Matherne as Logan Karole Foreman as Amelia's Mother Jason Edwards as Evidence Control Officer Gary Newton as Detective Mark Pettit as Reporter #3 Cheyenne Seleah as Josie Woodard Brian Gililland as Reporter #1 J.D. Wilhelm as TBD Jeff Bailey as Doctor