Guest Stars Geoffrey Cantor as Mitchell Ellison Amy Rutberg as Marci Stahl Kate Udall as SAC Tammy Hattley Sunita Deshpande as Seema Nadeem Matt Gerald as Melvin Potter Joe Jones as Felix Manning David Anthony Buglione as Agent Johnson Stephen Rowe as Nicholas Lee Matthew McCurdy as Agent Wellers Kelly McAndrew as Mrs. Shelby Noah Huq as Sami Nadeem Richard Prioleau as Agent Doyle Lee Tergesen voices Paxton Page Marlie Hall as Reporter #1 Bill Winkler as Warden Riggle Anthony Salvador Lewis as Reporter #3 Nandita Shenoy as Saanvi Nadeem Amy Halldin as Reporter #4 Antu Yacob as Carla Christopher Piccione as Parolee David Healy as Reporter #5 Karina Casiano as Betsy Beatty John Carey as Reporter #2