Guest Stars Amy Rutberg as Marci Stahl Peter McRobbie as Father Paul Lantom Kate Udall as SAC Tammy Hattley Sunita Deshpande as Seema Nadeem Joe Jones as Felix Manning David Anthony Buglione as Agent Johnson Don Castro as Agent Arinori Matthew McCurdy as Agent Wellers Kelly McAndrew as Mrs. Shelby Peter Halpin as Theo Nelson Noah Huq as Sami Nadeem Richard Prioleau as Agent Doyle Sam Slater as Agent O'Connor Andrew Sensenig as Agent Winn Michael Mulheren as Edward Nelson John Francis McNamara as Uncle Timmy Nelson John Patrick Hayden as "Battling Jack" Murdock Deirdre O'Connell as Anna Nelson Andy Lucien as Agent Ramsey Annabella Sciorra as Rosalie Carbone Ezra Knight as John Hammer John Nania as Agent Markham Kimberli Flores as Agent Alvarez Stephen Axelrod as Latimer Zyl Arden Wolfe as Nelson Niece Jonathan O'Reilly as Nelson Nephew Anne Carney as Aunt Jeanie Nelson Omar Corominas as Fight Referee Che Tafari as Marcus Ammie Montas as Novitiate Ellen Keet Davis as The Mark Ned Van Zandt as Everett Starr Isabella Pisacane as Novitiate Maggie Macaulee Rusnak Cassaday as Novitiate Ingrid Cori Dioquino as Sophia Carter Kelsey Schmitt as Allison Hattley