Guest Stars Andy Daly as Principal Brown Ben Schwartz as Nick Philip Anthony-Rodriguez as Tim Roy Jenkins as Kenny Christopher Darga as Lou Tessa Auberjonois as Nancy Co Starring Frankie A. Rodriguez as Eduardo Greta Jung as Mia Kristina Hanna as Tiffany Amy Tolsky as Guidance Counselor Chad Coe as Photographer Kevin Patrick Doherty as Brooks Nick Paonessa as Sean Griffen Campbell as Tyler Avery Tiiu Essex as Young Claire Nick Charles Currie as Student