Guest Stars Diedrich Bader as Bill Ericsson Hugh Laurie as Tom James Brian Huskey as Leon West Matt Oberg as Buddy Calhoun Patton Oswalt as Teddy Sykes Nancy Lenehan as Mrs. Ryan Paul Scheer as Stevie Margaret Colin as Jane McCabe Mary Catherine Garrison as Sophie Brookheimer Emily Pendergast as Beth Hennick Andy Daly as Keith Quinn Rhea Seehorn as Michelle John Carroll Lynch as Lloyd Hennick Co Starring Megan Grano as Donna Deb Hiett as Reporter #1 Sloane Letourneau as Clay Allen Rueckert as Reporter Crystal Hayes as Alethia James Rick Scarry as Meyer Fan Jimmy Tingle as Nick Spooner Jully Lee as Reporter Kiva Jump as Reporter Montana Roesch as Buzzfeed Reporter Eliza Shin as Reporter #2