Guest Stars Maggie Lawson as Natalie Flynn Shay Rudolph as Maya Paola Lázaro as Louie "The Gute" Gutierrez George Sharperson as Monty Jenkins Jonathan Sadowski as Andrew Simon Mykelti Williamson as Tom Barnes Lola Glaudini as FBI Agent Adam Shapiro as Kip Peter Parros as FBI Agent Co Starring JC Currais as Gus Richard Rubin as Radio Host Trevor Gretzky as FBI Agent Becker Rich Cetrone as El Tranquila David Olsen as Limo Driver