Guest Stars Penelope Ann Miller as Jessica Nevins Josh Hopkins as Peter Manning Esai Morales as Kyle Tyner Christopher Cousins as Judge Wallace Rainer Randy Oglesby as Mr. Jerome Robin Pearson Rose as Mrs. Jerome Michael O'Keefe as Bob Bianca Kajlich as Quinn Keeler Mia Korf as Tiersa Adams Juliette Goglia as Becca Jerome Elizabeth Lackey as Dr. Rachael Lawson