Guest Stars Kaliko Kauahi as Sandra Kaluiokalani Jon Barinholtz as Marcus White Bashir Salahuddin as Pastor Craig Co Starring Amir M. Korangy as Sayid Will McLaughlin as Earl Greenstein Jeff Witzke as Customer Waleed Mansour as Blender Customer Uncredited Danny Gura as Elias Selisha Shertick as Sarah Jon Miyahara as Brett Kobashigawa Mariana Tosca as Heather Christopher Riordan as Chris John Di Fatta as Jay