Guest Stars Tracey Ferencz as Detective Jenny Hicks Cara Gee as Alicia Pratta Megan Hutchings as Sorority Girl Janet Porter as Nancy Fornow Courtney Richter as Brittany Catherine Fitch as Catherine Paul Braunstein as Geoffrey Carson Carter Hayden as Trevor Leanne Poirier Greenfield as Veronica Pratta Gregory Calderone as Kevin Topp Madison Falle as Karen Nicole Dorsey as Megan