Special Guest Stars Kevin Durand as Jason Woodrue Guest Stars Ian Ziering as Daniel Cassidy / Blue Devil Given Sharp as Shawna Sunderland Elle Graham as Susie Coyle Al Mitchell as Delroy Tremayne Steve Wilcox as Burritt Sunderland Co Starring Dorothy Recasner Brown as Nadine Matt Burke as Gordon Haas Bianca Tarantino as Young Abby Eli Hannon as Young Avery Benjamin Keepers as Lee Coyle Andrew Yackel as Todd Will Swiss as Rowdy Partygoer Sam Proffitt as Clown Mark Everett Nabell as Creepy Jester Anderson Martin as Butler Corrina Jean Madrid as Harrased Girl Jeremy Owens as Pig Head Michael Trisler as Man with No Face Credit Only Selena Anduze as Caroline Woodrue