Guest Stars Blake Baumgartner as Kick Ryan Catherine Wolf as Rose Congemi Gloria Reuben as Eloise Hastings Sarah Shahi as Rachel Benham James Michael Cummings as Tommy Hayes Scott William Winters as Todd Hastings Rory Culkin as Clay Roach Georgina Reilly as Corie Struthers Mike Doyle as Josh Goshen J. Bernard Calloway as Captain Shag Lewis Cody Kostro as D.J. Joye Sharon Washington as Shirley Hanlon Kate Lyn Sheil as Tara Sheehan Kanoa Goo as Dave Kumagai Cristina Rosato as Christie Hayes Matthew Lawler as Ari Moore Co Starring Grayson Eddey as Tony Ryan Nora Murphy as Marie Ryan Lucas Van Engen as Sheik Sheehan Robert Wahlberg as Bernie Hannahan Charlene Almarvez as Yvette Kaishek Cara Marquis as Nikki Ryan Victoria Collett as Megan Ryan Brandon Tabassi as Joe Nazzarin Alma Cuervo as Female Juror David J. Cork as Male Juror Jeff Panzarella as Nick Giambra Stephen D'Ambrose as Evan Klondike Monique Alvarez as Grace Roshan Affolter as Waiter Marianne Noscheze as Hooker