Guest Stars Liza Lapira as Mia Dale Dickey as RoseMarie Omar Maskati as Elias Kai Lennox as Steve Rasmussen Scott Lawrence as Special Agent Billy Taggart Danielle MacDonald as Amber Stevenson Eric Lange as Detective Parker Austin Hébert as Max Duvall Max Arciniega as Jason Alvarez Jun Hee Lee as Officer Geoffrey Morris Annaleigh Ashford as Lilly Darrow Bill Fagerbakke as Detective Pruitt Jayne Taini as Doris Laird John Billingsley as Judge Tom Amandes as Bruce Bronstein Co Starring Blake Ellis as Chris McCarthy Connor Tillman as Officer Selig Tim Martin Gleason as Bennett John Hartmann as Hughes Dominic Goodman as Frat Bro #3 Keitrell Hamilton as DMV Passerby Jade Ramirez Warner as Patrice