Guest Stars Yara Martinez as Isabella Colón Mercedes Ruehl as Judge Tessa Hudson Ellen Adair as ADA Glover Sebastian Arcelus as Eric Crawford Alexie Gilmore as Lena Crawford Jack Gore as Charlie Crawford C.J. Adams as Theo Crawford Co Starring Lawrence Winslow as Det. Lacy Katt Masterson as Laura Coleman Robyn Rosario as Deb Erwin Isabelle Phillips as Juror #7 Bob Juergens as Juror #12 Sheilagh Weymouth as Juror #17 / Judith Stein K.C. Arora as Juror #22 Robin S. Walker as Juror #33