Guest Stars Daniel Di Tomasso as Fletcher Meyers Rob Nagle as Mitchell Erin Cummings as Erica Brown Co Starring Maura Gale as Judge Ruth Matthews Melissa Saint-Amand as Becky Katie Gunderson as Laura Jean Tennybelle Hayes Mercure as Tripp Worthington Anna Wright as Foreperson Jaidi Ventura as Roma Terrence Smith as Bartender Renu Razdan as Libby Winters