Guest Stars Felicia Day as Molly Lyndie Greenwood as Susan Wil Wheaton as David Gavin Stenhouse as Bennie Taylor Malcolm Barrett as Derrick Rachel Bloom as Ellie Amir Talai as Amir Motoki Maxted as Jax Jonah Ray as Matt Laurel Toupal as Becky Ben Weinswig as Andy Co Starring Alexander Ward as Animal Pooka Gene Freeman as Demon Pooka Laurie Perez as Reporter Willow Beuoy as Lauren