Guest Stars Laila Robins as Grace Mallory Shantel VanSanten as Rebecca "Becca" Saunders Butcher Nicola Correia-Damude as Elena Cameron Crovetti as Ryan Jessica Hecht as Carol Abraham Lim as Kenji Miyashiro Langston Kerman as Eagle the Archer David Thompson as Matthew Culbert / Gecko Adrian Holmes voices Dr. Park Co Starring Nneka Elliott as Female News Anchor Keana Lyn as Hostess Darrin Maharaj as Reporter Tanner Zipchen as Entertainment Reporter Julie Nolke as Reporter Charlotte Tavares as Susan Rayner's Daughter Heather Tod Mitchell as Mrs. Crowder Wyatt Lamoureux as Minister Caroline Lesley as Reporter Preeti Torul as Reporter Ethan Tavares as Susan Rayner's Son Massey Ahmar as Guard Tim Gammon as Susan Rayner's Husband John Moore as Reporter Vanessa Burns as Reporter Uncredited Patton Oswalt voices Gills