Guest Stars Josh Hamilton as Matt Jensen Steven Weber as Principal Gary Bolan RJ Brown as Caleb Joseph C. Phillips as Greg Davis Benito Martinez as Sheriff Diaz Nana Mensah as Amara Josephine Achola Inde Navarrette as Estela de la Cruz Parminder Nagra as Priya Singh Co Starring Austin Aaron as Luke Holliday Brandon Butler as Scott Reed David Douglas as Andrew Gerges Challen Cates as Evelyn Williams Chris Damon as Officer Uncredited Phylicia Rashad as Minister