Guest Stars Neil Jackson as Abraham Van Brunt Matt Barr as Nick Hawley Sakina Jaffrey as Sheriff Leena Reyes Co Starring Jeremy Owens as Headless Horseman Megan Hayes as Dana Dobbs Marc Farley as Gerry Scott Poythress as Benedict Arnold Sean Goulding as Dave Surely Alvelo as Terrytown Psych Nurse Kimberley Drummond as Sofie Joy Jacobson as Ms. Galway Stephen Michael Ayers as Shopkeeper Scott Depoy as Priest Reginald Lashaun Clay as Booking Sheriff
