Guest Stars Jennifer Ferrin as D.A. Avery Grafton Danny Mastrogiorgio as Nic Palermo Devale Ellis as Preacher Amy Hohn as Judge Felicia Cooley Joe Perrino as Dale Aldridge Co Starring Erica Camarano as Detective Paley Kyla Imani McMillan as Jasmine Alexis Suarez as U.S. Marshall Mike Monroe Lipica Shah as Elaine Gibson Brian Cade as Dr. Connor Geraghty Carole Denise Jones as Angela Lianne Marie Dobbs as Leslie Aldridge Daniel Siani as Blake