Guest Stars Kelly Schumann as Justine Sikowicz Jon Barinholtz as Marcus White Irene White as Carol Malloon Franchesca Ramsey as Nia Benjamin Norris as Tony Maria Thayer as Hannah Rory Scovel as Dr. Brian Patterson Dave Foley as Lowell Anderson Michael McMillian as Line-Cutting Customer Co Starring Will McLaughlin as Earl Greenstein Nicole Lynn Evans as Nicki Albert Kuo as Customer Uncredited America Ferrera as Amy Dubanowski Danny Gura as Elias Jon Miyahara as Brett Kobashigawa