Guest Stars Elizabeth Marvel as Counselor Rita Calhoun Leslie Odom Jr. as Reverend Curtis Scott Jefferson Mays as Dr. Carl Rudnick Korey Jackson as Brian Hoda Kotb as Herself Chad L. Coleman as A.J. Martin Meagan Good as Paula Lisa Kron as Judge Robin Schaeffer Jeb Brown as Officer Denard David Dinkins as Judge Chet Baker Co Starring Nick Walker as Former Teammate Brian Richardson as Jury Foreperson Ian O'Malley as League Official Uncredited Steve Zirnkilton voices Opening Narration
