Guest Stars Rosalyn Coleman as Judge Leconnell Yasha Jackson as Vanessa Voss Ryan Cooper as Jackson Martin Fulvio Cecere as Detective Paz Lana Young as ADA Weiss Jeff Adler as Billy Martin Co Starring Veracity Butcher as Juror #9 / Cecilia Williams John Austin Wiggins as Juror #3 Maggie Lakis as Woman Ali Bill as Reporter #1 Samantha Arthur as Sarah Norris Rebecca Nelson as Maryanne Norris Kristen Murphy as Sarah (Reenactment) Morgan McGhee as Server Daniel Siani as Young Billy Alexander Mulzac as Wheat Dean Neistat as Big Dude Bryce Biederman as Shadowy Figure Gabe Doran as Reed Johnson