Guest Stars Jennifer Tilly as Tiffany Valentine Fiona Dourif as Nica Pierce Carina Battrick as Caroline Cross Barbara Alyn Woods as Michelle Cross Alex Vincent as Andy Barclay Fiona Dourif as Charles Lee Ray Michael Therriault as Nathan Cross Christine Elise as Kyle Blaise Crocker as Young Tiffany Valentine Co Starring Annie Briggs as Miss Fairchild Nick A. Fisher voices Good Guy Doll