Guest Stars Johari Washington as Topher Dunn Eugene Byrd as Sam Tremont Jim Gleason as Bennett, Sr. Ethan Hutchison as Young Sam Robert Manning, Jr. as Elijah Tremont Co Starring Garrett Kruithof as Judge Emmett Walker Leslie Castay as Mrs. Roth Tadasay Young as Allison Carter Chris Alan Greening as Hiker #1 Presley Richardson as Student Haley Baird Riemer as Hiker #2