Special Guest Stars Kellita Smith as Judge Vonetta Sears Leonard Roberts as Judge Reinhardt Guest Stars Terrell Carter as Mark Ericsson Rodney Van Johnson as Rev. Barrington McCullough Andrew Oliveri as Frank Marzili Jack Impellizzeri as Peter Corbin Kevin Pasdon as Duke Salters Christopher Attoh as Vincent Haynes Co Starring Isaac Stephen Montgomery as Captain Warren Sloan Ellana Barksdale as Deidra "Big D" Walls Lizzie Peet as Sheriff Bobbi Olsen Wendi Bazar as Elena Marzili Bernardo Verdugo as Esteban Sousa Jordan T. Johnson as Benjamin 'Benji' Walls Daniel Bruce Kelly as Deacon Charles David Weisenberg as Richard Huffman Ben Vazquez as Deputy Garcia Dru Perez as News Reporter Scarlett Redd Kinnik Sky as LaDonna Mills Paige Annette as Safiye Haynes Asha Franklin as Othello's Lover Jibre Hordges as Hannibal Charles Lanee Jackson as Girl on Othello's Phone