Guest Stars Alanna Ubach as Suze Paula Marshall as Marsha Colman Domingo as Ali Zak Steiner as Aaron Nick Blood as Gus Martha Kelly as Laurie Henry Eikenberry as Derek Elias Kacavas as 18 Year-Old Cal Co Starring Chloe Cherry as Faye Marsha Gambles as Miss Marsha Yukon Clement as Theo Veronica S. Taylor as Bobbi Melvin Estes as Bruce Jason Medwin as Pee Wee Ref James C. Burns as Bud Audrey Walters as Young Cal's Mom Rebecca Louise Monaghan as 17 Year-Old Marsha Ernie Gonzalez Jr. as Vice Principal Joshua Hoyo Jr. as Meat Head Jock Brooklyn Brailsford as Hot Girl Joanne Baron as Judy Anouk Samuel as Lisa Christie Nicole Chaplin as Young Cal's Sister Bryan Charles Feldman as Ethan's Dad