Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Robert Clohessy as Sid Gormley Steven R. Schirripa as Anthony Abetemarco Ian Quinlan as Officer Luis Badillo Will Hochman as Joseph "Joe" Hill Eric B. as Lt. Mike Gee Stacy Keach as Archbishop Kevin Kearns Blake Morris as FBI Agent Jeff Green Erika Henningsen as Madeline Gleeson Daniel Reece as Mark Rowland Branden Lindsay as Lamar White Bobby Roman as Manuel Ruiz Co Starring Joe O'Connor as Officer Malone Mark McKinnon as Officer Miller Stephanie Ruiz as Mrs. Ruiz Finnerty Steeves as Joyce Stein Eileen Noonan as Legal Aid Attorney Isabel Renner as Marla Winters Ollie Corchado as Perez Natalie Melo as Ruiz's Daughter