Guest Stars Olivia Luccardi as Lily Day Drew Scheid as Travis Hupp Ben Chase as Nate Swanson Jesse Scott Egan as Detective Michael Merkel Adam David Thompson as Capt. Mike Lang Catherine Carlen as Bonnie Celia Weston as Shirley Neumann Heather Magee Thomas as Judge Mennemeyer Jeffrey Ryan Baker as Louis Gumpenberger Co Starring Keith Morrison voices Himself (Narrator) Susan Shalhoub Larkin as Luci Lara Grice as Cousin Mary Barry Clifton as Jerry Randall D. Cunningham as Polygrapher
