Guest Stars Jarell Sullivan as David Roberts Rebecca Spence as Jessica Rossi Malkia Stampley as Marisol Madison Dirks as Marty Gallagher Jon Michael Hill as Pastor Richards Kamal Angelo Bolden as Officer Young Erik Hellman as Peter Matthew Elam as TJ James Vincent Meredith as Dr. Algren Michael Patrick Thornton as Judge Fitzpatrick Patrick Mulvey as Michael Rossi Steve Pickering as Robbie Logan Kara Zediker as TBD