Special Guest Stars Alexandra Breckenridge as Sophie Guest Stars Adam Korson as Elijah Blake Stadnik as Jack Damon Auden Thornton as Lucy Patrick Mulvey as Grant Alexis Krause as Laura Ayesha Harris as Lawyer Co Starring Johnny Kincaid as Jack Jr. Kellan Tetlow as Nicky Jr. Callie Carlin Ogden as Franny Sophia Sawaya as Hailey (6 y/o) Karl Seitz as Jack Jr. (7 y/o) Mary Garripoli as Sheila Lisa Carswell as Dr. Dianne Winslow Daniel Tatar as Realtor Karlee Morgan Eldridge as Kevin's Date Mel Mehrabian as Leslie
