Guest Stars Scott Michael Campbell as Brigham Young Zachary Ray Sherman as Porter Rockwell Co Starring Taylor St. Pierre as Jacob Lafferty Megan Leitch as Doreen Lafferty Britt Irvin as Sarah Lafferty Rohan Mead as Morris Emily James as Ron Lafferty Girl 1 Sienna King as Annie Pyre Alba Evora Weiler as Caroline Pyre Beau McHattie as Ron Lafferty Boy 2 Nicholas Carella as Brady Jerod Blake as Desk Cop Barclay Hope as Chief Rick Belnap John Innes as Stake President Stowe Lori Bachynski as Brenda's Neighbor Hannah Galway as Betty Wright Dean Paul Gibson as Prophet Onias Shane Ghostkeeper as Convenience Store Clerk Joelle Farrow as Flora Frank Moore as General Authority Lorette Clow as Mrs. Stowe Steven McCarthy as John Taylor Chanelle Peloso as Debbie Alexandra Castillo as Female Detective Ben Rose as Higbee Kurt Evans as FBI Agent Simon Longmore as Circus Circus Security #1 Ron Anderson as Morman Miner William Belleau as Paiute Leader Israel Lachovsky as Doctor / Priesthood Holder Nancy Boyd as Brigham's Wife #1 Caroline Buzanko as Arkansan Leader's Wife Annabel Beames as Doctor's Daughter Evan Buliung as Major John D. Lee Dylan Roberts as Peppermill Dealer David LeReaney as Reno Captain Peter Deiwick as LDS Colonel Lonni Olson as Casino Security Rep #2 Laurent Pitre as Ricky Dean Barrett as Reno Policeman Kevin Corey as Arkansan Doctor Karen Ryan as Brigham's Wife #3 Michael Lipka as Chip Carnes Jag Arneja as Pakistani Driver Cliff Liknes as Arkansan Leader Tiffany Helm as Brigham's Wife #2