Guest Stars Richard Kind voices Marty Glouberman Joe Wengert voices Caleb Paula Pell voices Barbara Glouberman Chloe Fineman voices Leah Birch June Diane Raphael voices Devin Thandiwe Newton voices Mona Jessica Chaffin voices Shannon Glaser Seth Morris voices Greg Glaser Joe Wengert voices Lump Humpman Brian Tyree Henry voices Elijah Jenny Slate voices Caitlin Grafton Cole Escola voices Montel Peter Capaldi voices Seamus McGregor Brandon Kyle Goodman voices Youth Group Teacher Jeff Goldblum voices The Apple Brooch