Special Guest Stars Wilmer Valderrama as Special Agent Nicholas "Nick" Torres Gary Cole as Special Agent Alden Parker Yasmine Al-Bustami as Special Agent Lucy Tara Vanessa Lachey as Special Agent in Charge Jane Tennant Guest Stars Kavi Ladnier as NCIS Reserve Agent Shyla Dahr Lesley Boone as Nina Barnes Maya Stojan as Morgan Miller Jose Pablo Cantillo as Pierce Co Starring Stephen Mendel as Jimmy McCann