Guest Stars Andrew Terraciano as Sean Reagan Abigail Hawk as Det. Abigail Baker Gregory Jbara as DCPI Garrett Moore Robert Clohessy as Sid Gormley Steven R. Schirripa as Anthony Abetemarco Ian Quinlan as Officer Luis Badillo Will Hochman as Joseph "Joe" Hill Stephanie Kurtzuba as Captain Paula McNichols Bonnie Somerville as Paula Hill Erika Slezak as Donna Duvall Erin Anderson as Naomi Dixon Justin Rodriguez as Felix Jim Ferris as Carl Ben Thompson as John Dixon Michael Tourek as Bob Youngblood Co Starring James Nuciforo as Jim Nuciforo Matt Consalvo as Officer Meyers Hanna Edwards as Wanda Ronnie Castellano as Dwayne Austin Elle Fisher as Elyse Mullins Michael Cash as Colin Kila Ever as Annie Hunter Thore as Wayne Austin Green as Elyse's Dad